I’ve spent decades chasing lone-wolf RPGs and watching speedrun streams for mechanical tricks. When Zojoi opened its Shadowgate vault after 30 years, I jumped in with equal parts curiosity and doubt. Beyond Shadowgate calls itself a point-and-click giant—five times bigger than the NES original. That’s a bold promise, and it mostly delivers. However, bringing back an old style can sometimes exaggerate its quirks.

Screenshot 8

Overall Impressions

Beyond Shadowgate thrives on nostalgia and size. It brings back that eerie castle feel while adding new puzzles and side areas at every turn. Compared to modern adventure games—like the slow-burn puzzles of Return of the Obra Dinn or the playful depth of Thimbleweed Park—this one leans into a classic, no-frills style. You’re dropped into dark halls with almost no guidance. Midway, the shift to lighthearted humor felt sudden, echoing complaints that it veers into LucasArts territory. Still, the mix never fully breaks the main mood.

Screenshot 7

Gameplay Mechanics

The core point-and-click loop still works: explore rooms, examine items, combine inventory pieces. Zojoi’s new real-time system adds urgency, but it sometimes punishes logical item orders. For instance, you must mix red potions into green, not the other way around—an old MacVenture trap. Some players found this backward logic cheap. I did too during a demo run, dying where common sense should prevail. Fast travel alleviates backtracking between landmarks, yet interior staircases remain a slog. Fetch quests cluster in high school–style telephone chains that disrupt pacing. Still, standout moments emerge when you cleverly reassemble a shattered relic or dodge a rampaging gargoyle. Those bits feel earned.

Screenshot 6

Story and Characters

The storyline casts you as the new heir exploring the Warlock’s castle to lift an ancient curse. Characters mostly arrive as cryptic quest-givers or undead adversaries. The world-building drips with potential but often skims by without full exposition. A few NPCs share witty asides, yet most chatter hits a terse, 8-bit limit. Player feedback notes that humor frequently interrupts tension—imagine solving a dire riddle, then reading about your hero tripping over a banana peel. It undercuts scares but also injects sporadic charm. I appreciated the lean narrative for encouraging player inference, though I craved deeper explanations of the Warlock’s motives and the castle’s lore.

Screenshot 5

Visuals and Graphics

Graphically, Beyond Shadowgate marries pixel art with modern color depth. Stone walls feature convincing moss, and flickering torchlight casts dynamic shadows. The 16-bit-style palette evokes the original while feeling refreshed. Animations remain minimal—doors slide, torches sway, skeletons lunge—but that restraint suits the genre. A handful of scenes, like a blood-soaked crypt or a lily-padded pond, deliver genuine atmosphere. Occasionally background tiles repeat too obviously, reminding you of production constraints. Still, overall art direction nails the balance between homage and contemporary pixel polish.

Screenshot 4

Sound and Music

Composer Ken Allen (of the 2014 remake) returns with a mostly chiptune score that hums with brooding melodies. While none of the tracks reached earworm status for me, they consistently underpin exploration and danger. Sound effects—creaking doors, dripping water, distant screams—add texture but rarely spook. Some audio cues appear misplaced, such as jaunty music after a failed puzzle, which feels tone-bendy. No voice acting appears here, keeping it pure to its roots. For series veterans who still hum the NES Shadowgate theme, this new soundtrack offers enough nods to satisfy without eclipsing its predecessor.

Screenshot 3

Difficulty and Replayability

Beyond Shadowgate calibrates itself as “fairly forgiving” compared to the original’s brutal death traps. You’ll still die from logical reversals and unseen pitfalls. Yet checkpointing softens the sting. Players have recorded full runs in under 90 minutes, unlocking a speedrun achievement. I clocked about four hours on my first playthrough at a measured pace. A second run revealed alternate endings, and achievement hunters can chase time trials or hidden Easter eggs referencing Deja Vu and Uninvited. While puzzles skew more telegraphed than cryptic, the game’s sheer volume and multiple outcomes tempt replays. I plan a third pass just to test out every joke and shortcut.

Screenshot 2

Final Thoughts

Besides occasional tonal whiplash and under-hinted item combos, Beyond Shadowgate stands as the best Shadowgate sequel we’ve seen. It balances homage with thoughtful expansions. Zojoi’s gamble on resurrecting a 30-year-old design largely pays off—if you can forgive the clumps of fetch quests and the odd banana-peel comedy breaks. For point-and-click fans craving depth, a hint of speedrun fun, and a healthy dose of castle dread, this one merits a place in your library. In the immortal words of that dubious Warlock: “Proceed at your own risk”—just don’t forget to mix your potions correctly.

Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

Add Beyond Shadowgate to your Steam collection!