Sea of Thieves: A Pirate’s Dream or a Speedrunner’s Nightmare?

Ahoy, mateys! Prepare to set sail on the high seas with “Sea of Thieves,” a game that promises the essential pirate experience. If you’ve ever dreamed of being a swashbuckling pirate, then this game might just be the treasure you’ve been searching for. However, for a speedrunner like me who’s more inclined towards precision and efficiency, this genre can be a mixed bag. Let’s dive into the good, the bad, and the downright scurvy aspects of this ambitious title.

Open-World Pirate Adventure

“Sea of Thieves” is an open-world pirate adventure game where you can explore vast unspoiled islands, underwater kingdoms, and engage in epic battles against both AI-controlled foes and other players. The game offers a high degree of freedom with no set roles, meaning you can choose to play in whatever style suits you best—be it solo or as part of a crew.

screenshot_0_Sea of Thieves: A High-Seas Adventure or a Sinking Ship?

Detailed Ship Mechanics

The mechanics are fairly straightforward; you sail your ship, search for treasure, and engage in naval combat. The ship handling mechanics are quite detailed, requiring cooperation among crew members to manage sails, cannons, and repairs. While this offers an immersive experience, it can be cumbersome and slow-paced for those who prefer the quick, efficient gameplay commonly found in speedrunning.

Stunning Visuals

Visually, “Sea of Thieves” is nothing short of spectacular. The game features a vibrant, cartoony art style that brings the world to life. The water effects are particularly impressive, capturing the essence of the open sea with stunning realism. However, the repetitive environments can sometimes feel monotonous despite their initial charm.

screenshot_1_Sea of Thieves: A High-Seas Adventure or a Sinking Ship?

Sandbox Experience

The game doesn’t offer a traditional narrative structure, opting instead for a sandbox experience where you create your own stories. While this allows for plenty of player freedom, it also means there’s a lack of cohesive storyline or character development. As someone who enjoys diving into rich, well-crafted narratives, this was a bit disappointing.

Strong Sense of Community

One of the best parts of “Sea of Thieves” is the sense of community it fosters. Whether you’re coordinating with your crew to take down a mighty Kraken or engaging in epic ship battles with other players, the cooperative aspects are where the game really shines. The constant updates and seasonal content ensure that there’s always something new to explore, keeping the game fresh and engaging over time.

screenshot_2_Sea of Thieves: A High-Seas Adventure or a Sinking Ship?

Flaws and Frustrations

However, “Sea of Thieves” isn’t without its flaws. The lack of structured gameplay can sometimes lead to aimless wandering and repetitive tasks, which can get boring quickly. For a speedrunner like me, the game’s slower pace and occasional grind can be frustrating. Additionally, the game’s reliance on multiplayer means that solo players might find it challenging to make significant progress.


In the end, “Sea of Thieves” is a mixed bag. Its beautiful visuals, sense of community, and freedom to explore make it a unique and enjoyable experience for those who are fans of open-world and cooperative games. However, the lack of a structured narrative, repetitive tasks, and slower pace might not appeal to everyone—especially those of us who thrive on speed and precision.

Rating: 3 out of 5 stars

screenshot_3_Sea of Thieves: A High-Seas Adventure or a Sinking Ship?

If you’re looking for a rich, high-seas adventure and enjoy creating your own stories, “Sea of Thieves” might just be your perfect game. But if you prefer a more structured, fast-paced experience, you might find yourself feeling like you’re adrift at sea.

screenshot_4_Sea of Thieves: A High-Seas Adventure or a Sinking Ship?

Useful Gaming Tip for Beginners

Tip: Focus on communication and cooperation with your crew. Efficient teamwork can make managing your ship and handling combat much smoother, enhancing the overall experience.

Want to check it out yourself? Click here to see it on Steam.